Question 6

Organisation structure: its purpose, its importance and how clearly its levels can be identified

18.75 marks

Time to write
About 38 minutes

From an older CBCS paper

Question

Question 6 · 18.75 marks

Give your views on structure, its purpose and importance. To what extent, do you think, are there clearly identified different levels within the structure of an organisation?

Reworded from the university paper; the task is the same. The original paper belongs to the University of Delhi. See DU's question bank.

Before you write

Read off the question and its marks

38 minfor 18.8 marks

Read from the question

  • Give…What…?Two asks in one question: answer both.

Write it in this order

  1. Read; underline the asks; jot your points 2 min
  2. 1 Meaning of organisation structure, with views 3 marks 6 min
  3. 2 Purpose of structure 3 marks 5 min
  4. 3 Importance of structure 4 marks 7 min
  5. 4 Extent to which levels are clearly identified 5½ marks 10 min
  6. 5 Illustrative case 2½ marks 5 min
  7. 6 Conclusion 0.8 mark 1 min
  8. Check: every ask answered, key terms underlined 2 min

Easy marks

  • Step 1 opens with the meaning: a one-line definition, the quickest mark in it.

Short on time? Trim steps 1–5 evenly rather than skip one: each is capped at its own marks. End with step 6 in a line or two.

Try it first. About 38 minutes for 18.75 marks. Write it out, then open the solution.

Solution

Hover or tap a marked figure, like 72,000, to see how it is made and where else it appears.

What organisation structure is

Organisation structure is the framework within which managerial and operating tasks are carried out. It sets out the relationships between people, work and resources, allows human, physical and financial resources to be linked and coordinated, and is usually shown in an organisation chart. It is the outcome of organising: the work is identified and divided, similar activities are grouped into departments, duties are assigned to suitable people, and authority and reporting relationships are fixed. The structure deliberately designed in this way is the formal organisation, which states who is to do what, with whom and under whose supervision; alongside it an informal organisation of personal relationships grows up on its own.

My view is that structure is a means, not an end. It exists to make plans work, so the right structure depends on the organisation's size, activities and environment. There is no single best structure for all organisations or for all times: a firm with one main product line can group work by function, while a diversified firm may need divisions, each run as a profit centre for its own product line.

Purpose of structure

  1. To translate plans into action. Organising, and the structure it creates, is the means by which plans are put into effect.
  2. To remove ambiguity. By designing roles and defining how they relate, structure clarifies the extent of each person's authority and responsibility for results.
  3. To integrate the parts. Structure regulates and coordinates the responsibilities of individuals and departments so that the enterprise works as one unit.
  4. To support communication and control. A proper structure ensures a smooth flow of communication and better control over operations.

Importance of structure

Peter Drucker stressed that structure is an indispensable means and that the wrong structure can seriously harm business performance or even destroy it. Its importance shows in several ways:

  1. Room for growth. A good structure lets a firm add positions, departments, product lines and territories. The need for an adequate structure is felt whenever a firm grows in size or complexity, and a firm that never changes its structure may stagnate.
  2. Clear working relationships. It specifies who reports to whom, which removes confusion in passing information and instructions and fixes responsibility.
  3. Specialisation. Systematic allocation of jobs lets people perform a specific task repeatedly and become expert at it.
  4. Adaptation to change. The structure can be modified and relationships between levels revised as the business environment changes, giving the firm stability while it adjusts.
  5. Best use of resources. Proper assignment of jobs avoids overlapping and duplication, and so reduces waste of resources and effort.
  6. Development of managers. Delegation within the structure relieves managers of routine work, giving them time to innovate, and lets subordinates develop their abilities.

An effective structure, in short, raises profitability.

Are there clearly identified levels within a structure?

The case for clear levels. In a formal organisation, authority is greatest at the top and narrows step by step down the hierarchy. The authority-responsibility relationship binds people as superiors and subordinates and so gives rise to levels; generally there are three:

LevelWhoMain task
TopChairman, chief executive, functional chiefsIntegrate the whole, set goals and strategy, answer for survival and social impact
MiddleDivision and department headsInterpret policies, staff and motivate their units, carry out top management's plans
SupervisoryForemen and supervisorsOversee the workforce directly, maintain quality, cut waste, keep safety standards

. The scalar principle also calls for clear lines of authority from top to bottom, and the clearer they are, the better the performance.

The case for caution. The three levels are a general pattern, not a fixed rule. The number of levels follows from the span of management: a wide span gives few levels, a narrow span many. No exact span suits every case: it depends on how well subordinates are trained, how clearly authority is delegated and plans are drawn, whether objective standards exist, how fast the firm changes and how well its managers communicate. The boundaries between levels also blur. The top management team includes heads of functions such as finance and marketing, and middle managers are at once subordinates of the top and superiors of the first line. Electronic business tends towards flat structures with direct communication in every direction rather than a tall hierarchy; in network organisations status and rank differences are minimal; and with flat structures gaining ground, authority is increasingly read as empowerment of employees. Alongside the formal levels, informal groups form spontaneously out of personal interaction and shape their members' behaviour.

My conclusion on this part is that levels are clearly identifiable in most formal structures, especially large and stable ones, but their number and sharpness vary, and in small, fast-changing or networked firms they are much less distinct.

Applying this to an illustrative case

Consider a hypothetical food-delivery start-up in Bengaluru. With twenty people, the founders talk to everyone directly: there are effectively two levels and no organisation chart. At two thousand staff across ten cities, confusion over who decides what forces a structure: functional heads for technology, operations, marketing and finance at the top, city managers in the middle, and shift supervisors directing delivery partners on the ground. The three levels are now clear. Yet the technology team still works in small, flat squads with wide spans, while city operations keep narrow spans because conditions change by the hour. The same firm thus shows clear levels in one part and blurred ones in another, which is why the extent of clearly identified levels depends on the work being organised.

Conclusion

Structure is the framework that turns plans into coordinated action, clarifies authority and responsibility, and lets a firm grow and adapt. Levels of management exist wherever authority is passed down, and three levels are common, but how many there are and how sharply they are drawn depends on the span of management and on the nature of the organisation.

Where the 18.75 marks sit

#ComponentMarks
1Meaning of organisation structure, with views3
2Purpose of structure3
3Importance of structure4
4Extent to which levels are clearly identified5.5
5Illustrative case2.5
6Conclusion0.75
Total18.75
Keyboard: ← → previous and next question, / search

Report a problemopens an email to admin@getkunji.com with the question IDBOMP21-Q6already filled in.